CLOSED CHURCHES WITHIN THE
PRESENT BOUNDARIES OF THE
SUSQUEHANNA CONFERENCE OF
THE UNITED METHODIST CHURCH
The information for each
church is arranged in alphabetical order within counties. Select a county.
Adams | Bedford | Blair | Bradford | Centre | Clearfield | Clinton | Columbia | Cumberland | Dauphin | Franklin | Fulton | Huntingdon| Juniata | Lackawanna | Luzerne | Lycoming | Mifflin | Montour | Northumberland
| Perry | Pike | Potter | Schuylkill | Snyder | Sullivan | Susquehanna | Tioga | Union | Wayne | Wyoming | York
BLAIR COUNTY PA
1. Allegheny Chapel UB
[no picture]
Location:
Municipality:
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Historic Conference:
Allegheny Conference of the United Brethren
Church
Journal references:
1915,70 –
mentioned as existing in 1895
Brief History:
This building is mentioned on
page 126 of Fulton’s 1931 History of the
Allegheny Conference as once being a part of the Tyrone/Blair circuit. It may have been near Baughman’s Cemetery
near Tyrone, as services in Allegheny Chapel are mentioned in connection with
burials as Baughman Cemetery.
Final disposition:
2. Altoona EV
Location: 11th Avenue
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Eleventh Avenue runs parallel to, and a block west of, the
railroad tracks and is in the old section of Altoona. The church building
stood on the east side of the street, between 14th and 15th Streets. The
1873 atlas of Blair County indicates the exact location.
Historic Conference:
Pittsburgh Conference of the Evangelical
Association
Journal references:
Brief History:
Altoona was included in the part of the Central
Pennsylvania Conference split off in 1851 to create Pittsburgh
Conference. This congregation/building dates from 1870, but appears to
have been short-lived. Emanuel is the only Evangelical Association congregation
listed in Altoona in Wiley's 1892 county history.
Final disposition:
The site is occupied by the modern building pictured
above.
3. Altoona Chestnut Avenue ME
Location: Chestnut Avenue and 10th Street
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Chestnut Avenue runs parallel to, and 3 blocks west of, the
railroad tracks and is in the old section of Altoona. The church building
stood on the southeast corner of Chestnut Avenue and 10th Street.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
1887,44 –
auditorium addition completed and dedicated February 1887
Brief History:
This congregation was organized in 1871 by members of
First Church who objected to the organ in use at that building. They met
in Elway's Hall and were served by the pastor of the Logan Valley
Circuit. The annual conference of 1872 granted their request to be
assigned a pastor. As the congregation grew, the cornerstone for the
above building was laid October 7, 1874, and the building was dedicated June
13, 1875. Membership peaked at 454 in 1894, and then began a gradual
decline. In 1913 Chestnut Avenue united with Walnut Avenue to form Grace
Methodist Episcopal Church and erect the structure on Fourth Street at Walnut
Avenue.
Final disposition:
A modern commercial building now occupies the
site.
4. Altoona Eighth Avenue UMC
[Second ME]
[Faith UM]
Address: 712 13th Street
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
Eighth Avenue runs north-south, just
west of the main north-south [PA 764] routes through Altoona, which are 7th
Avenue (south bound) and 6th Avenue (north bound). The church property is
on the northeast corner of 8th Avenue and 13th Street, but the building was
destroyed by fire, and the site is now an empty lot.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of
the Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
Brief History:
This congregation was historically
known as Eighth Avenue Methodist Church. The need for a second
congregation east of the main tracks arose after the railroad split the growing
town of Altoona, and the First Methodist Episcopal Church was in the older area
west of the main tracks. When the cornerstone was laid in 1868 the
building known as the Second Methodist Episcopal Church, but the name had been
changed to Eighth Avenue by the time the structure was completed in 1870.
That first building was replaced by the structure picture above, for which the
cornerstone was laid in 1901.
There was also a nearby congregation known as First
Evangelical Church, which became Faith Evangelical United Brethren [EUB] Church
following the 1946 denominational merger, and Faith United Methodist Church
following the 1968 denominational merger. In 1972 that congregation sold
their building and united with Eighth Avenue, with the united congregation
using the Eighth Avenue building and the name Faith United Methodist
Church. Over the years the congregation decreased and the maintenance
costs on the building increased. In 2007 the congregation voted to raze
the structure and to rebuild a smaller, modern, energy-efficient church
building either at the 8th Avenue and 13th Street site or at some other
location. After razing the building pictured above and meeting at various
locations for a few years while trying to determine a course of action, the
members opted to merge into the Wehnwood
congregation.
Final disposition:
The site is an empty lot.
5. Altoona East Altoona Chapel ME
[no picture]
Address: 6th Avenue and 6th Street
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of
the Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal
References:
1872, 31 – cost
$600, dedicated September 1871, connected with Eighth Avenue ME
Brief History:
Knox’s 1909 History of Methodism in
Altoona, page 59, states in connection with Eighth Avenue: “During Rev.
Monroe’s ministry [1871-72], the home missionary spirit showed itself in the
building of two chapels: the one on Sixth Avenue and Twenty-fifth Street, and
the other on Sixth Avenue and Sixth Street, which was then in the woods.
Final
Disposition:
6. Altoona East End UMC
[Third UB]
Address: 405 E. Hudson Avenue
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
The church is
in the northeast section of Altoona. Hudson Avenue is three blocks east
of Walton Avenue [PA 764], the main north-south street
in northeast Altoona.
Historic Conference:
Allegheny Conference of the United
Brethren Church
Journal references:
Brief History:
In the United Brethren denomination
this congregation was known as Altoona Third. It had its beginnings when
two women from Altoona Second [now Second Avenue] canvassed the East End
community in 1895 the interest of a Sunday School.
Sessions were held in a school house, the ministry prospered, and the present
church building was completed in 1906.
East End UMC voted to close held its
final worship service on December 31, 2023.
Final disposition:
The property (church and
adjacent parsonage) was sold at auction on 7/25/2024 for $166,100.
7. Altoona Emanuel EV
Location: 5th Avenue & 5th Street
Municipality: city of
Altoona
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
In the city of Altoona, 5th Avenue runs north & south
and is one block east of 6th Avenue, the northbound lanes of PA 764. The
numbered streets cross the numbered avenues, with 1st Street at the north end
of the city. The church is on the southeast corner of 5th Avenue and 5th
Street.
Historic Conference:
Pittsburgh Conference of the Evangelical
Association
Journal references:
Brief History:
Altoona was included in the
part of the Central Pennsylvania Conference split off in 1851 to create
Pittsburgh Conference. This congregation was formed in 1884 with 21
charter members. The origin of the congregation was actually in Germany –
as 10 of the 21 charter members had been converted there under John C. Link at
an Evangelical mission established in Germany by American missionary Sebastian Kurz in 1851. This
congregation first worshiped in a schoolhouse between Fifth and Sixth Avenues
until the first church building was erected in 1887. The present structure was dedicated in
1906. It remained with the Evangelical
Association during the 1894-1922 denomination split, during which time the
Central Pennsylvania Conference established United Evangelical congregations in
the city. Following the 1922 denominational re-union, the old
affiliations were preserved and the city of Altoona was served by two
Evangelical Conferences. Emmanuel remained in the Pittsburgh
Conference and was surrounded by congregations of the Central Pennsylvania
Conference. The congregation was "discontinued" by the Western
Pennsylvania Conference of the EUB Church in 1956 when the pastor and members
of Emmanuel left the denomination.
Final disposition:
The building houses an independent congregation.
8. Altoona Fifth Avenue UMC
Address: 407 Fifth Avenue
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
Fifth Avenue runs north-south, just
east of the main north-south [PA 764] routes through Altoona, which are 7th
Avenue (south bound) and 6th Avenue (north bound). The church property is
on the southeast corner of 5th Avenue and 4th Street.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of
the Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
1887,44
– dedicated October 1886
Brief History:
In 1883, members of the Eighth
Avenue Church living in the area saw the need for a new congregation in this
growing section of Altoona. At a quarterly conference of the Eighth
Avenue Church, trustees for the new project were elected. The
congregation was officially charted in 1885, a frame structure was erected in
1886, and by the following year it was necessary to build an addition to the
church. By 1890 the congregation had 325 members, and in 1892 a parsonage
was erected. When the nearby Italian Methodist Church (northwest corner
of Eighth Avenue and 6th Street) closed in 1941, Fifth Avenue received a
plurality of its members and many of the church furnishings. Attendance
dwindled over the years and the congregation was placed on a two-point charge
with Jaggard Memorial. The congregation
eventually voted to disband, and the final service was held December 27, 2009.
Final disposition:
9. Altoona Faith UMC
[First EV]
Location: 6th Avenue and 11th Street
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
In the city of Altoona, 6th Avenue runs north & south
and is the northbound lanes of PA 764. The numbered streets cross the
numbered avenues, with 1st Street at the north end of the city. The
church is on the southeast corner of 6th Avenue and 11th Street.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Evangelical Church
Journal references:
1930,54 – new
auditorium dedicated 2/23/1930
Brief History:
Since 1851 this part of Pennsylvania had been part of
the Pittsburgh Conference of the Evangelical Association. The 1896 annual
session of the Central Pennsylvania Conference of the United Evangelical Church
determined "that Altoona and adjacent territory be taken up as a mission
to be supplied as soon as possible." In 1898 a class was organized
with 13 charter members. A plot of ground was purchased, the existing
building remodeled for worship services, and a parsonage erected on the rear of
the lot. The original building was replaced with the present sanctuary in
1928. Following the denominational union of 1946 the congregation became
known as Faith Evangelical United Brethren Church. In 1972 the
congregation joined with nearby Eighth Avenue [former Methodist] Church,
with the united congregation taking the Faith name and using the Eighth Avenue
facilities.
Final disposition:
The connected parsonage to the rear has been torn
down. The church building remains and is now Mother Gethsemane Church of
God in Christ.
10. Altoona First UMC
Address: 1208 13th Street
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
This church is in the old section of Altoona west of the main railroad
tracks, south of the Altoona Hospital. Seventh Street (westbound) and
Eighth Street (eastbound) are the arteries that cross the main railroad
tracks. Once in the western section of Altoona, the church building is on
the northwest corner of 12th Avenue and 13th Street.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of
the Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal
References:
Brief History:
The 1850's influx of people associated with the development of Altoona
and the Pennsylvania Railroad included many Methodists, and they formed a
society and met in a school house. By 1853 the class had grown to the
point that they asked to be organized as a separate charge with their own
pastor. That same year they secured from Colonel John A. Wright the two
plots of land on which the present church stands and erected a large brick
building with, as was the style, the sanctuary on the second floor. That
building was remodeled in 1871, razed in 1905, and replaced by the present
structure in 1907. This is the mother church of Altoona Methodism. The final service for the congregation was
June 26, 2011, and on July 1, 2011, the congregation formally merged into Jaggard Memorial to become Jaggard
First UMC.
Final
Disposition:
The building
has been sold and is now home to the non-denominational Center City Church.
11.
Altoona
Garden Heights UMC
[Lakemont
Terrace UB]
Address: 109 Bellview
Street
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
The church is
in the southeast section of the city, just north of Logan Boulevard [PA 36]
between Pleasant Valley Boulevard [business US 220] and the US 220 [I 99]
by-pass. Bellview Street crosses Logan
Boulevard about halfway (about 4 blocks in either direction) between Pleasant
Valley Boulevard and the US 220 underpass. The church is on Bellview Street one block north of Logan Boulevard.
Historic Conference:
Allegheny
Conference of the United Brethren Church
Journal References:
1928,85 –
chapel dedicated 1/29/1928
Brief History:
This congregation began as a
union Sunday School meeting in an abandoned school
house. In 1926 the pastor and congregation of the Greenwood United
Brethren Church used this as a basis for outreach to the people of the growing Lakemont-Garden Heights section of Altoona. A canvass
of the area indicated a desire for a church, and in 1927 a two-point mission
was established consisting of Garden Heights and a similar year-old project
across town in the Wehnwood section. A parsonage
was purchased for the pastor at 201 Mosser Street,
and frame chapel with a cement block basement was erected adjacent to the
parsonage. The first service was held in chapel December 18, 1927, and a
United Brethren congregation was organized January 29, 1928, with 50 charter
members. The present sanctuary was dedicated April 9, 1950, and the
educational unit was added in 1954. In 1959 the property across from the
church was purchased as the site for a new parsonage - which was completed and
occupied in 1966.
Final Disposition:
12.
Altoona
Grace EV
[Otterbein UMC]
Location: 10th Avenue and 3rd Street, Juniata
section of Altoona
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Juniata, once a separate town, is the northwest section of
Altoona. Chestnut Avenue is the main north-south road one block west of
the railroad tracks in Altoona. Take Chestnut Avenue north into the
Juniata section, where it becomes 4th Avenue, to 3rd Street. Turn left on
3rd Street and go 7 blocks to 10th Avenue. The church is on the southeast
corner.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Evangelical Church
Journal references:
2005,S2 - all members transfer
to Juniata United Methodist
Brief History:
This congregation was established by the 1906 annual
conference as a mission appointment. The Church Extension Society
purchased three lots at the present location, and a Sunday School
building was erected there in 1908. The worship auditorium was added in
1925. In 1969 the Otterbein (former United Brethren) congregation merged
into Grace, with the united congregation taking the Otterbein name and using
the Grace facilities. In 2005 the 3 United Methodist congregations in the
Juniata section of Altoona formed a single congregation worshiping in the
former Methodist structure at 8th Avenue and 4th Street and known as the
Juniata United Methodist Church of Altoona.
Final disposition:
In 2023 the
building was home to the Altoona Restoration Church of God.
13. Altoona Grace UMC
Location: 4th Street, Altoona
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
In the old section of Altoona, west of the railroad tracks, 4th
Street is a major east-west route running along the north side of the
hospital. Go about 4 blocks west of the tracks on 4th Street to Walnut
Street. The church is on the northeast corner of 4th Street and Walnut
Avenue.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
2009,S2 - end the year with 105
members
2009,360 - not in the list of appointments
Brief History:
This congregation was formed in 1913 by the union of the
Chestnut Avenue and Walnut Avenue Methodist Episcopal congregations. The
present building was dedicated in December 1914. The congregation
dwindled over the years, and efforts to merge with Fairview or some other
Altoona United Methodist congregation proved unsuccessful. The
congregation was dropped from the list of appointments in 2009, and the
building became the responsibility of the conference trustees.
Final disposition:
The building is now owned
and used by an independent Baptist congregation.
14.
Altoona Italian
ME
Location: 6th Street
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
In the city of Altoona, 8th Avenue runs north & south and
is one block west of 7th Avenue, the southbound lanes of PA 764. The
numbered streets cross the numbered avenues, with 1st Street at the north end
of the city. The church property was three lots extending west from
the northwest corner of 8th Avenue and 6th Street. The church building
stood on the center lot, and the other properties were used as the parsonage
and as rental units.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
1910,69 –
dedicated 2/27/1910; total cost $5,000
1928,624 – permission to sell
Brief History:
Because of its employment opportunities, Altoona
received hundreds of Italian immigrants in the late nineteenth century.
When the Methodist Church addressed many of the social and economic needs of
the newcomers, many of them turned to that denomination for their spiritual
needs. Since few of the immigrants spoke English, the conference arranged
in 1904 for an Italian-speaking pastor to lead the work. The sanctuary
was dedicated in 1910. Worship services in Italian and other ministries
to the community continued until 1941, when there no longer appeared to be a
need for an ethnic ministry. A detailed history of the congregation is
given on pages 50-63 of the 1995 volume of The Chronicle.
Final disposition:
The property was sold to the Pennsylvania Railroad, the
adjacent land owners, in 1942. The church building and the other
structures were razed, and the site is an empty lot.
15. Altoona Otterbein UB
Location: 6th Avenue and 6th Street, Juniata section of
Altoona
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Juniata, once a separate town, is the northwest
section of Altoona. Chestnut Avenue is the main north-south road one
block west of the railroad tracks in Altoona. Take Chestnut Avenue north
into the Juniata section, where it becomes 4th Avenue, to 6th Street.
Turn left on 6th Street and go 2 blocks to 6th Avenue. The church is on
the southeast corner.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania
Conference of the Methodist Episcopal Church
1927,426
– permission to sell church & parsonage in preparation for relocation
Allegheny Conference of the United Brethren
Church
Journal references:
Brief History:
This building was actually built by the Methodists, and
was the site of the second church building of what is now Juniata United
Methodist Church at 8th Avenue and 4th Street ― their
first building having been at 5th Avenue and 7th Street. The building was
dedicated by the Methodists on January 3, 1903, and used until they moved to
their present building in 1927.
The United Brethren organized a Sunday School in Juniata in 1910, attached the work to Greenwood in
1911, and purchased lots on which to build in 1912 ― but then the work
was suddenly discontinued. The work was revived in 1923, and the
following year a sectional chapel was formally dedicated on the previously
mentioned lots. When the work prospered, the congregation purchased the
former Methodist building, which they repaired and dedicated as a United
Brethren structure on November 6, 1927. Otterbein Church functioned until
1969, when they joined with Grace Church (former Evangelical) ― the
united congregation taking the Otterbein name and using the Grace facilities at
10th Avenue and 3rd Street. In 2005 the 3 United Methodist congregations
in the Juniata section of Altoona formed a single congregation worshiping in
the former Methodist structure at 8th Avenue and 4th Street and known as the
Juniata United Methodist Church of Altoona.
Final disposition:
The site now houses an independent congregation.
16.
Altoona
Pleasant Valley UMC
[Fourth]
[Grace]
Location: Pleasant Valley Boulevard
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Pleasant Valley Boulevard is business route US 220, the main
highway skirting the east side of the city of Altoona. The highway
divides, and the church is located on the northeast corner of the southbound
Pleasant Valley Boulevard and 13th Street.
Historic Conference:
Allegheny Conference of the United Brethren
Church
Journal references:
1927,132 – detailed history of the
establishment of the congregation and the present property
1928,84 –
cornerstone laid 12/11/1927 for Altoona Grace on Pleasant Valley Boulevard
1928,86 – building dedicated 5/9/1928
Brief History:
In 1925 the Church Extension and Missionary Society of
the United Brethren Church projecting establishing a congregation in the
growing Pleasant Valley section of Altoona. Devotional services were held in the
homes of various prospective members. Three lots on the corner of East Fourteen
Street and Adams Avenue were purchased.
A portable chapel was erected and dedicated December 13, 1925. In
1926 a parsonage was purchased, and in 1927 the original three lots were
declared “not being in a satisfactory location due to the development of the
community since their purchase” and the present church property was purchased
and ground was broken for a permanent place of worship. The building
pictured was dedicated May 6, 1928. Originally known as Altoona Fourth
UB, the name of the appointment was changed to Grace in 1927 and to Pleasant
Valley in 1938.
For most of its existence, Pleasant Valley was a station
appointment with approximately 200 members. In 1970 it was placed on a
two-point charge with nearby Jaggard Memorial [former
Methodist]. That arrangement lasted until 1995, when other charge
structures were experimented with. By 2000 the congregation had dwindled
to a membership of 87. In 2002 Pleasant Valley [former Fourth UB] merged
into East End United Methodist [former Third UB].
Final disposition:
17. Altoona Second Avenue UMC
Address:
130 Second Avenue
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
Second Avenue runs north-south, a
few blocks east of the main north-south [PA 764] routes through Altoona, which
are 7th Avenue (south bound) and 6th Avenue (north bound). The church is
in the north end of town at the northwest corner of Second Avenue and 2nd
Street.
Historic
Conference:
Allegheny Conference of the United
Brethren Church
Journal references:
Brief
History:
Originally named Second United
Brethren Church, this is a daughter congregation of the former First
United Brethren Church (which stood at 8th Avenue and 12th Street, was re-named
Trinity United Methodist in 1968, and merged into Second Avenue in 1996).
The congregation continued the pattern when they later gave birth to Third
United Brethren Church (now East End United Methodist). Their first
building was erected in 1888 on Fifth Avenue, between Second and Third
Streets. The present structure was dedicated September 4, 1927, as Second
Avenue United Brethren Church. In 1955, an impressive 6 feet 4 inches
tall wood carving "The Kristus" was placed
in niche behind the altar ― making it one of the first churches in the
United Methodist tradition to have such a figure in the chancel.
On 3/5/2023 the congregation
voted 76-26-2 to disaffiliate from the United Methodist Church, and that
disaffiliation along with 140 others was approved at a 5/17/2023 special
session of the Susquehanna Conference.
18. Altoona Schum Memorial UMC
Address: 4200 Broad Avenue, Altoona 16602
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
Broad Avenue is a major north-south street in
Altoona, about four blocks west of PA 764. The church is in the south end
of the city, at Broad Avenue and what would be 42nd Street. When going
south on Broad Avenue, there is a jog to the right at 40th Street. Broad
Avenue is also known as Oak Avenue in the neighborhood of 58th Street.
Historic Conference:
Allegheny Conference of the United
Brethren Church
Journal
References:
Brief History:
In the early 1900's, the people of
the community erected a church building which became Grace Lutheran
Church. In 1925 that building was purchased by the United Brethren
denomination, remodeled, and formally dedicated on June 7, 1926, with 70
charter members. It was named Schum Memorial in
honor of Henry Schum,
a faithful layman and treasurer of the congregation's mother church, Altoona
First United Brethren (which stood at 8th Avenue and 12th Street, was re-named
Trinity United Methodist in 1968, and merged into Second Avenue in 1996).
Major additions and/or separate buildings enlarged the congregation's facilities
in 1953, 1969, and 2002. In 2007 Schum
Memorial united with Fifty-Eighth Street to form Christ Community United
Methodist Church, operating out of the former Fifty-Eighth Street location, and
the Schum campus continued temporarily as community
ministry.
Final
Disposition:
The property is now the independent
Lighthouse Church and School.
19.
Altoona
Simpson UMC
Address: 2216 6th
Avenue
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
Sixth Avenue forms the northbound
lanes of the main north-south route [PA 764] through Altoona. The church
property extends on the west side of Sixth Avenue from 22nd Street to 23rd
Street.
Historic
Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of
the Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
1887,45 –
“moving toward” building at a new location
2023,275 – sold 3/14/2022 for $165,000
[part to Lutherans] to Adam S. Rhine
Brief
History:
The year was 1872, and the only
Methodist church in the area was over a mile away at Eighth Avenue and 13th
Street. Simpson Methodist Episcopal Church began one block west of its
present location, in the Seventh Avenue home of Mrs. Susannah W. Chatams ― a gifted woman
concerned about the children and unchurched adults in the neighborhood. A
Sunday School was organized in May of that year, and
by October the crowds were so large that property was secured and a chapel
erected at the corner of Seventh Avenue and 24th Street. A brick
sanctuary was erected at the northwest corner of Sixth Avenue and 23rd Street
in 1888, and replaced by a larger building of Hummelstown brownstone in
1905. A large Christian education building extending along Sixth Avenue
was completed in 1957. In 1982, after 11 years of cooperative ministry
and dialogue, the congregations of Simpson United Methodist Church and the
adjacent Temple Lutheran Church formally merged into a united parish. The
following year plans were begun to raze the deteriorating Simpson sanctuary,
but to use the 1957 education building for the united congregation. As
part of that decision, and symbolic of the cooperation of the two
congregations, the Simpson (installed 1914) and Temple (installed 1927) organs
were combined into a single organ of 38 ranks, or 2,220 pipes. The picture
above shows the empty lot that once housed the Simpson building, the Simpson
education building, and the rear of the Temple sanctuary in which the
Simpson-Temple congregation new worships.
Final disposition:
20.
Altoona Trinity
[First UB]
Location: 1129 8th
Avenue
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
In the city of Altoona, 8th Avenue runs north & south
and is one block west of 7th Avenue, the southbound lanes of PA 764. The
numbered streets cross the numbered avenues, with 1st Street at the north end
of the city. The church is on the northeast corner of 8th Avenue and 12th
Street. The 1873 atlas of Blair County indicates the exact location.
Historic Conference:
Allegheny Conference of the United Brethren
Church
Journal references:
1915,48 – parsonage changed into SS
addition, made part “in architecture and utility”
Brief History:
United Brethren camp meetings were held on the farm of
Samuel McGlathery, now the corner of 20th Avenue and
20th Street in the city of Altoona, in 1848. A class was organized in
1850. The congregation met successively at the McGlathery
farm, a school house on Howard Avenue (between 10th and 11th Streets), the
Union Chapel on 16th Street (between 11th and Union Avenues). The Union
Chapel was a school house occupied on alternate Sundays by the Methodist and
United Brethren congregations. In the winter of 1855-56 the United
Brethren held a powerful revival in the Baptist Church then located on 11th
Avenue. The church became a station appointment and purchased the lot at
8th Avenue and 12th Street.
The first building was erected in 1856, and the structure
picture above was erected at the same site in 1899. This is the mother
church of seven other United Brethren congregations: Second [Second Avenue]
1887, Third [East End] 1895, Juniata Otterbein 1910, Schum
memorial 1925, Pleasant Valley 1925, Wehnwood 1925, and
Garden Heights 1927. Following the denomination union of 1968 the
congregation became known as Trinity United Methodist Church. After years
of the declining membership experienced by many inner-city congregations,
Trinity merged into one of its daughters, Second Avenue United Methodist, in
1996.
Final disposition:
The building is unused.
21. Altoona Walnut Avenue ME
Location: Walnut Avenue and 3rd Street, Altoona
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
In the old section of Altoona, west of the railroad tracks,
4th Street is a major east-west route running along the north side of the
hospital. Go about 4 blocks west of the tracks on 4th Street
to Walnut Street. Turn right on Walnut Street and go 1 block to 3rd
Street. The church stood on the northwest corner of Walnut Avenue and 3rd
Street, on the site now occupied by the houses known as 1502 & 1504 3rd
Street.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
Brief History:
This congregation began in the summer 1889 when a Mr. W.
Lee Woodcock noticed neighborhood children with no Sunday School
to attend. He arranged with a Mr. S.E. Hedding
to erect a second floor meeting room over his place of business. By the
end of the year the Sunday School was ministering to
over 100 persons each week and attracting the attention of members of First
Church and Chestnut Avenue Church who lived in the area. A congregation
was organized, property was purchased, and the cornerstone for the above
building was laid in June 1891. Originally, with Fairview, part of the
two-point North Altoona charge, it became a station appointment in 1901 and
continued to grow. In 1913 Walnut Avenue united with Chestnut Avenue to
form Grace Methodist Episcopal Church and erect the structure on Fourth Street
at Walnut Avenue.
Final disposition:
The site is occupied by two houses moved from the site
of the new Grace Methodist Episcopal Church on Fourth Street.
22. Altoona Wesley UMC
Location: 6th Avenue and 15th Street, Juniata section of
Altoona
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Juniata, once a separate town, is the northwest section of
Altoona. Chestnut Avenue is the main north-south road one block west of
the railroad tracks in Altoona. Take Chestnut Avenue north into the
Juniata section, where it becomes 4th Avenue, to 15th Street. Turn left
on 15th Street and go 2 blocks to 6th Avenue. The church is on the
southeast corner.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
Brief History:
Blair Furnace is now known as East Juniata, the northern
end of the Juniata section of Altoona. In 1900 a Union Sunday School was
operating in the area, and the farmland was being laid out in lots to
accommodate the northward expansion from Altoona and Juniata. The
Methodists from the Union Sunday School approached the conference about buying
lots and erecting a church in the new development, which apparently was
projected to ne known as Blair City. The
conference agreed. Lots were purchased, and a building was dedicated December
13, 1903. The cornerstone reads "Cherry Avenue ME Church, Blair
City, 1903" ― as 6th Avenue was known at
that time as Cherry Avenue, and 15th Street was known as Spring Street.
The church was always on a charge with the nearby rural Asbury Church. In
2005 the 3 United Methodist congregations in the Juniata section of Altoona
formed a single congregation worshiping in the former Methodist structure at
8th Avenue and 4th Street and known as the Juniata United Methodist Church of
Altoona.
Final disposition:
23. Bakers Mines ME
[no picture]
Location:
Municipality:
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
Brief History:
Final disposition:
24. Bellwood Calvary UMC
Address:
601 N. Fourth Street, Bellwood 16617
Municipality: borough of Bellwood
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
Cross [on PA 865] the bridge over the railroad tracks to the west side of
town and go 4 blocks. The church is on
the southeast corner of PA 865 [Tuckahoe Street] and Fourth Street.
Historic
Conference:
Allegheny Conference of the United
Brethren Church
Journal references:
1891,18
– church building being erected
1892,23 – church building dedicated
4/20/1892
Brief
History:
This congregation began in the Antis
United Brethren building, erected in the present Antis Cemetery south of town
in 1832. The structure at the present
site was erected 1891/92 and used some materials from the Antis Church. Substantial improvements were made to the
structure over the years. In 1952, the
Grace Evangelical congregation merged into Calvary, and the educational annex
was dedicated in 1953.
On 1/24/2023 the congregation voted 30-0
to disaffiliate from the United Methodist Church, and that disaffiliation along
with 140 others was approved at a 5/17/2023 special session of the Susquehanna
Conference.
25. Bellwood Grace EV
Location: N. Second Street
Municipality: borough of Bellwood
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
From the intersection east of Bellwood of business route US
220 and PA 865, take PA 865 west into Bellwood. Cross over the railroad
bridge to the second street, N. 2nd Street. Turn right on N. 2nd
Street and go 1 block to Antes Street.
The church stood on the right side of N. 2nd Street, on the
southeast corner of N. 2nd and Antes.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Evangelical Church
Journal references:
1909,151 – Bellwood church
matter referred by Church Extension Society to Trustees
1910,116 – Bellwood granted loan of $150
Brief History:
Since 1851 this part of Pennsylvania had been part of
the Pittsburgh Conference of the Evangelical Association. The 1896 annual
session of the Central Pennsylvania Conference of the United Evangelical Church
determined "that Altoona and adjacent territory be taken up as a mission
to be supplied as soon as possible." The presiding elder [district
superintendent] surveyed the area and found 12 persons at Bellwood willing to
form a congregation. The work was supplied for the rest of the year, and
in 1897 an appointment was made for a pastor to reside in Bellwood and preach
at Altoona, Bellwood and Pinecroft. The church
building at Bellwood was completed in 1900, and the adjacent parsonage about a
year later. The 1946 denominational union created two Evangelical United
Brethren congregations in Bellwood. In 1952 Grace merged into Calvary
[former United Brethren]. The church and parsonage were sold, and the
money was used to erect a Sunday School addition at
Calvary.
Final disposition:
The church site is an empty lot, but the parsonage shown
above at the right is still standing on N. 2nd Street.
26. Bellwood Trinity UMC
Address: 533 Main Street, Bellwood 16617
Municipality: borough of Bellwood
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
Enter Bellwood from the east on PA
865. Main Street is the last street
before crossing over the railroad tracks to the west side of town. The church is 2 blocks south on Main Street,
on the southeast corner of Tuckahoe and Main Streets.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
2023,181 – closed 6/28/2023
Brief History:
This class was organized February 23,
1844, with eight charter members meeting at the Antis school house. On January 2, 1869, a frame church was dedicated
where the parsonage now stands. The
present stone structure was dedicated May 23, 1897.
Citing “exigent circumstances”, the
Cabinet of the Susquehanna Conference voted to close this church 6/23/2023.
Final disposition:
The property was sold at auction on
3/16/2024.
27. Bennington ME
Location: Bird Eye Road: along the north side of the
railroad tracks, about 1 mile east of the Gallitzin tunnel
Municipality: Allegheny township
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
The post office was named Bennington Furnace. The site is difficult to reach. Either
(1) From the borough of Tunnel Hill in Cambria County,
go east on the dirt road out of town, bear to the right, go about 1 mile.
OR (2) From Sugar Run Road, the service road between US 22 and the
railroad, drive back to the south side of the tracks, by the east end of the
tunnel. Park and walk east along the tracks for about 0.5 miles.
The 1873 atlas of Blair County indicates the exact location.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
1872,31 – cost $1200, dedicated
1/7/1872
1872,95 – first listed in Missionary
Report with Duncansville circuit
1888,138 – listed in Missionary
Report with Allegheny circuit [also 1889,98 and 1890,117]
1900,153 – listed in Missionary
Report with Allegheny circuit
1903,141 – listed in Missionary
Report with Altoona circuit
Brief History:
Bennington is now a ghost town, with no structures
remaining. Prior to 1898, 100 men were employed by the furnaces located
here. The Bennington Furnace class developed from one of the adjunct area
Sunday Schools started by the Duncansville congregation. The church building was dedicated January 7,
1872, and the land was formally deeded to the Methodist Episcopal Church by the
Blair Iron and Coal Company on February 24, 1872. The congregation was originally part of the
Duncansville circuit.
Final disposition:
28. Blair Furnace ME
[no picture]
Location: 4th Avenue and 15th Street, Juniata section of
Altoona
Municipality: city of Altoona
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Blair Furnace, once a separate town, is now known as East
Juniata ― the northern end of the Juniata
section of Altoona. Chestnut Avenue is the main north-south road one
block west of the railroad tracks in Altoona. Take Chestnut Avenue north
into the Juniata section, where it becomes 4th Avenue, to 15th Street.
The church stood at this intersection.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
1876,40 - church building
dedicated
Brief History:
About 1874 the Methodist pastor from Bell's Mills
[Bellwood] conducted a brush meeting [series of evangelistic services held
outdoors in a grove] at Blair Furnace. This resulted in the formation of
a class. A church building was dedicated February 4, 1876. Along
with nearby Asbury, the church was on the Logan Valley charge. When the
work at Blair Furnace began to diminish, the population dwindled. The
congregation disbanded in 1885, and the building was sold at a sheriff's sale.
Final disposition:
29. Canoe Creek UMC
Address: US
Route 22, Canoe Creek
Municipality: Frankstown township
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
From Hollidaysburg, go 7 miles east on US
22. The church is on the south side of
the highway.
Historic
Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of
the Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal
references:
1889,60 – at Canoe Creek, Duncansville circuit, a plain, comfortable
church furnished at a cost of $800, and dedicated free of debt
Brief
History:
This congregation began when area persons
purchased an old school house and erected, at their own labor and expense a
church house on the site in 1888. They
walked to Williamsburg to ask the pastor there to supply the preaching. The
1898 conference statistics list it as an appointment on the McKee’s Gap
charge. That building was torn down in
1920 and rebuilt at the present site, being dedicated in 1921. In 1970 the congregation received the members
of the former Canoe Creek EUB church, which is now a bat sanctuary.
On 5/7/2024 the congregation voted to
close, and the final service was held 5/19/2024.
Final
disposition:
Sold at auction on 7/18/2024 for $50,6000.
30. Canoe Creek UB
Address: Turkey Valley Road
Municipality: Frankstown
township
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
From the interchange of US 22 and PA 866, go 2 miles west on
US 22 to Turkey Valley Road, which skirts the western edge of Canoe Creek
State Park. Turn right on Turkey Valley Road and go 1 mile. The
church is on the left. The 1873 atlas of Blair County indicates the exact
location.
Historic Conference:
Allegheny Conference of the United Brethren
Church
Journal references:
1970,93 - merged into Canoe
Creek [former Methodist]
Brief History:
This building was erected prior to 1873 and was part of
the 4-point East Freedom charge (Canoe Creek, East Freedom, Mount Moriah and
Pine Grove). Some area United Brethren materials refer to a Beaver Dam
appointment. As there was only one United Brethren building in the area,
Canoe Creek and Beaver Dam may be different names for the same
appointment. In 1973 the former UB and ME congregations in Canoe Creek
joined to form the Canoe Creek United Methodist Church, meeting in the former
ME building on US 22.
Final disposition:
The building is now the renowned Frank Felbaum Bat Sanctuary bat sanctuary, owned and managed by
the Pennsylvania department of Conservation and Natural Resources.
31. Duncansville Hicks Memorial UMC
Address:
1201 Third Avenue
Municipality: borough of
Duncansville
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
Third Avenue is US 22. The church
is on the south side of the highway, opposite of where 12th Street
goes off to the north.
Historic
Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
Brief
History:
This society was organized in the
1850’s and erected their first building in 1868. That structure is still standing just east of
the present complex and is now a print shop.
The present building was dedicated November 26, 1916, and financed by
Captain Alfred Hicks of Pittsburgh as a memorial to his parents, who had been
charter members of the society. The
matching adjacent [former][ parsonage was dedicated in
1919. In 1986 a new parsonage was
purchased and the house beside the church remodeled into office and classroom
space.
On 12/11/2022 the congregation voted
126-12 to disaffiliate from the United Methodist Church, and that disaffiliation
along with 140 others was approved at a 5/17/2023 special session of the
Susquehanna Conference.
32. East Freedom ME
Location: Everett Road, village of East Freedom
Municipality: Freedom township
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
East Freedom is on the old US 220, 9 miles south of
Altoona. Everett Road is the original US 220, running parallel to and
east of business route US 220. The church site is on Everett Road just
south of Freedom Street, the main east-west cross street, on the east side of
the road. The 1873 atlas of Blair County indicates the exact location.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
Brief History:
The first building at this site as a log frame structure
erected by the Methodists in 1845. They abandoned the appointment in 1879
when a new church building was completed in nearby McKee, and the property was sold
to the United Brethren – who erected the brick structure pictured above in
1907.
Final disposition:
The property is now home to the East Freedom United
Methodist Church. The brick building pictured was razed following the
erection by the new owners of the Sunday School
structure seen in the rear. The intended new sanctuary was never built,
and the site of the Methodist building is now part of the parking lot.
33.
East
Freedom UMC
Address: Everett Road, town of East Freedom
Municipality: Freedom township
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
Everett Road is the original US 220. Freedom Street is the east-west road that is
PA 164 leaving town heading to the west and is the road through the gap to
McKee heading to the east. The church is
on the southeast corner of Everett Road and Freedom Street.
Historic Conference:
Allegheny Conference of the United
Brethren Church
Journal references:
2016,147 - discontinued
Brief History:
The original log frame house of worship at
this site was erected by the Methodists in 1845. When the Methodists erected a building in
McKee in 1879, this appointment and congregation transferred to that location,
and the building was sold to the United Brethren in 1880. In 1883 the six point East Freedom charge was
formed to include East Freedom, Pine Grove (Puzzletown),
Mt. Moriah (Blue Knob), Ore Hill, Canoe Creek, and Beaver Dams. The last record of the Ore Hill church at
quarterly conference is in December 1901.
The Beaver Dams appointment was terminated in 1906. It is not known if the denomination own property
at those locations.
In 1902 the United Brethren erected a new
brick building. The existing cement
block building, an annex to which a new sanctuary would later be attached, was
erected in the 1960’s. In 1968 the brick
building was torn down and all services moved into the annex. The projected new sanctuary was never built.
Final disposition:
34. Frankstown UMC
Location: old US 22, Frankstown
Municipality: Frankstown
township
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Old US 22 is north of and parallel the present
highway. The church is on the north side of the street, near the east end
of the street. The 1873 atlas of Blair County indicates the exact
location.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
1925,72 – new church building dedicated
5/17/1924
1981,225 - merged into Hollidaysburg First
1982,258 - sale in progress
Brief History:
The first church
in Frankstown was a small frame building at upper end
of town that was blown down by a severe storm and never rebuilt. A union church was later erected on ground
donated by William and John Ling. This
building, which eventually became solely Methodist, was destroyed by fire in
1922 and the existing structure was dedicated on the same site 5/18/1924.
For many years the Frankstown church and parsonage were the base of the Frankstown Methodist charge, which included various rural
appointments over the years. Then Frankstown
and Altoona Lakemont were a 2-point charge until Lakemont and Garden Heights [former United Brethren] were
made a 2-point charge in the reorganization following the 1968 denominational
union. The congregation dwindled, and in 1981 the remaining members
merged into Hollidaysburg First.
Final disposition:
The property was sold in 1982 to Burkholder's Antique
Shop to be used for storage.
35.
Glen
White ME
Location: Glen White Road
Municipality: Logan township
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Glen White Road is the extension of 40th Street heading west
out of Altoona. The road changes names several times before it passes the
Horseshoe Curve site and becomes Glen White Road. The community of Glen
White was about 2 miles past the Horseshoe Curve. The community no longer
exists, and the exact site of the church is unknown.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
1889,60 – foundations laid for new building
1888,138 – listed in Missionary
Report for Allegheny circuit [also 1889,98 and 1890, 117]
1891,60 – new building dedicated November 30, 1890
1900,153 – last listed in Missionary
Report for Allegheny circuit
Brief History:
The community of Glen White was along an abandoned
railroad that joined the main line at the Horseshoe Curve. It owed its existence
to the rail lines which served the local coal mines. Later the area was
the site of the Forest Park Amusement Park and Forest Zoo ―
some buildings of which still remain, as the one pictured above.
Glen White was on the Allegheny Circuit.
Final disposition:
The area is abandoned.
36. Hollidaysburg EV
[no picture]
Location:
Municipality:
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Historic Conference:
Pittsburgh Conference of the Evangelical
Church
Journal references:
Brief History:
This mission was established in 1850 with
Lewis May as pastor, who served for two years.
1852 it was served by Peter Heiss. In 1853 the mission was transferred to the
Pittsburgh Conference, which had been formed in 1851, and served for more than
20 years. No further information is
available about the congregation or any property it may have owned.
Final disposition:
37. Hollidaysburg UB
[no picture]
Location:
Municipality:
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Historic Conference:
Allegheny Conference of the United Brethren
Church
Journal references:
Brief History:
In the book Blair County’s
First One Hundred Years: 1846-1946, the writer of the United Brethren section
claims “the denomination had a church in Hollidaysburg for a number of
years.” No further information is available
about the congregation or any property it may have owned.
Final disposition:
38. Ironsville UMC
Location: Ironville Road, village
of Ironville
Municipality: Snyder township
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
From the interchange of US 220 and PA 453 on the west edge
of Tyrone, go 2 miles east on PA 453 to Ironville
Road. Make a sharp right on to Ironville road
and go 0.5 miles. The church is on the right.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
1896,64 –
construction in progress
1897,60 – church dedicated
1980,268 – discontinued
1987,286 – sold
Brief History:
The name Ironsville is now
more commonly rendered as Ironville. The iron
works here began operating about 1885. Sunday School
was held in the Elk Run Schoolhouse, later the site of the Amisite
plant. The preacher from the Birmingham charge began holding services
every other week, and a successful revival meeting prompted the erection of a
church building. The building was finished in 1896. The church was
on the same circuit for its entire existence ― named
the Birmingham circuit until 1947, when that circuit was re-named the
Bald Eagle circuit and the parsonage was moved to Bald Eagle. The
membership dwindled over the years and was down to 17 in 1968. The
appointment was officially discontinued in 1980.
Final disposition:
The building is unused and unimproved.
39. Loop St. Paul's UMC
Location: off Loop Road, village of Loop
Municipality: Frankstown
township
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
From Frankstown, go south on
Reservoir Road (the only road that goes south across the river and the
railroad) 2.0 miles to Loop Road and the community of Loop. Turn left on
Loop road. The church is off Loop Road to the left.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
1936,89 –
building free of debt for first time since being built in 1921
1970,201 – permission to
sell
1973,204 – sold
to Loop Community Church
Brief History:
The history of this appointment is unclear. It
appears to have begun about 1920 when young families living in the area known
as the Loop wanted a church in their community. The met in an old school
building, now torn down, for a while before moving into a vacant one-story
structure. The appointment was not part of a circuit, and it seems to
have been served "under" Hollidaysburg ―
but by someone other than the pastor at Hollidaysburg. Services were
discontinued about 1966 and the building stood empty for several years before
finally being sold.
Final disposition:
The property was sold to the Loop Community Church in
1972.
40. Martinsburg UMC
Location: S. Market Street, Martinsburg
Municipality: borough of Martinsburg
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Market Street is PA 866. The church is on the
west side of the street near the center of town, 1.5 blocks south of the
intersection of PA 866 [Market Street] and PA 164 [Cove Mountain Road].
The 1873 atlas of Blair County indicates the exact location.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
1909, 80 – cornerstone laid 8/23/1908;
building dedicated 3/21/1909
1992,S-2
– membership transferred
1996,316 – building sold
Brief History:
The first Methodist society in Martinsburg was formed in
1819 when Daniel Bloom moved into the area. The first church was built in
1826. A brick structure was erected in 1843 and still exists as the
Sunday School wing of the existing complex. The
sanctuary was built in 1908, and in 1926 a basement/fellowship hall was placed
under the 1843 structure.
Martinsburg appointment was originally part of the
Williamsburg circuit. In 1867 the Martinsburg circuit was formed:
Martinsburg, Woodbury, Loysburg, Yellow Creek
[Bedford Forge], Pattonsville, Bakers and Roaring
Spring. In 1885 Martinsburg and Roaring Spring became a separate
two-point charge. When Roaring Spring grew enough to become a station
appointment, the Martinsburg circuit was reformed in 1890: Martinsburg,
Woodbury, Loysburg, Yellow
Creek. That charge remained intact for over 100 years, until Martinsburg
merged into Woodbury in 1992 to form the present Faith United Methodist Church.
Final disposition:
The building was sold and has been used for offices and
a day care.
41. Mt. Etna ME
Location: Fox Run Road
Municipality: Catharine township
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Go 5 miles west of Water Street on US 22 to Polecat Hollow
Road. Turn left on Polecat Hollow Road and go 2 miles to the T at Fox Run
Road. The church is at the intersection, on the right. The 1873
atlas of Blair County indicates the exact location.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
1912,93 – re-roofed
1943,29 – permission to sell
1958,159 – sold for $150; proceeds to
Mines Church
Brief History:
Final disposition:
6/18/1958 conference
trustee minutes – Mt. Etna church sold for $150.00, money given to Mines Church
(see also minutes for 6/25/1957 and
11/8/1957)
42. Mt. Moriah UMC
Address: PA 164, west of Blue Knob
Municipality: Juniata township
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
From East Freedom PA on old US 220, go 9
miles west on PA 164. The church is on
the right, 1 mile past the crossroads at Blue Knob.
Historic Conference:
Allegheny Conference of the United
Brethren Church
Journal references:
Brief History:
The first church building at this site was
erected in 1885 and destroyed by lightning in 1951. A larger structure was erected at the same
location and dedicated in 1955 with a membership of over 100, but it too was
destroyed by fire in 1973 – one of several fires set simultaneously in the Blue
Knob area by an arsonist. The present
modern structure was dedicated June 2, 1974.
Final disposition:
The church building and cemetery
were sold 2/14/2017 for $500 to the Mt. Moriah Cemetery Association of Blue
Knob.
43. Mt. Zion ME
Location: along the railroad tracks, about 1 mile north of
Tipton
Municipality: Antis township
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
From Grazierville,
go south on old US 220 to the bridge over the railroad tracks. Immediately after the bridge, bear right onto
McFarland Road (the original old US 220).
Continue 0.5 mile on McFarland Road to Forest Cabin Lane. Turn right on Forest Cabin Lane and proceed
0.1 mile to the at-grade crossing of the railroad tracks. To reach the church site, proceed across the
tracks and then follow the tracks south 0.2 miles. The cemetery is in the clump of trees on the
right, and the church stood site is now part of the railroad bed. The church site likely extended from the
railroad back to McFarland Road, opposite the point where the utility wires and
the remnant of the old road to Fuoss Mills head to
the east.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
1876,155 - historical statement
Brief History:
There are conflicting reports about this appointment and
church building. The 1876 conference journal states that there was early
Methodist preaching in Sinking Valley at the home of David Beyer, and that in
1833 Beyer moved from Sinking Valley to a farm near Tipton. There reportedly living in the area was an
old man named Samuel Eaken, who had once been a Methodist
and had actually heard John Wesley preach in Ireland. In 1836 a class was
formed, and in 1841 the society erected Mt. Zion Church. The appointment
is last listed in the Missionary Reports in 1872. Tipton first appears in
the records in 1879, and with many of the same names that were listed with Mt.
Zion. It appears that the Tipton church is considered the continuation of
the Mt. Zion church, even though it seems the two congregations/building
co-existed for a few years.
The history of the Tipton Church gives the following
account: "In the year 1834, a group of Methodists met and organized the
First Methodist Church in Mount Zion, Huntingdon (now Blair) County. A
church building was erected and a burial ground laid out near what is now known
as Fuoss Mills. The burial ground is still
discernable. On September 2, 1849, a right of way was granted to the
Pennsylvania Railroad Company. The document was signed by Aaron Beyer,
John Sheer, David Utley, Charles Welsh and Louis Palmer as trustees of Mount
Zion Church. The right of way necessitated the razing of the church
building. A plot of ground was obtained in Tipton, just north of the
present United Methodist Church, and a brick building was built. The
brick building was replaced by a frame building in 1872. The frame building
burned in 1879 and was replaced by the present structure in
1880."
[The above statement that the Mt.
Zion building was razed soon after the railroad agreement appears to be
erroneous, and it is believed the original Mt. Zion building was in use until
it was destroyed by fire in 1877.]
There is an old
cemetery cornerstone that reads "Mt. Zion 1807-1957." This, and
the wording "First Methodist Church in Mount Zion" suggests that the
community and/or cemetery near Fuoss Mills may have
been known as Mount Zion before the church was erected. It appears that the 1807 cemetery was
originally Baptist.
Final disposition:
The church site
is now part of the railroad bed. The
ownership of the adjacent cemetery is unclear.
44. Pine Grove UB
Location: Puzzletown Road,
village of Puzzletown
Municipality: Freedom township
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Newry is 2 miles south of
Duncansville on business route US 220. At the main intersection in Newry, turn west on to what becomes Puzzletown
Road. Go three miles to the village of Puzzletown.
The church is on the left, in the west end of Puzzletown.
Historic Conference:
Allegheny Conference of the United Brethren
Church
Journal references:
1945,36 -
disbanded, permission to sell
1946,126 - sold
Brief History:
This class was organized in 1863, but apparently
did not erect their first church building until after 1873. That building
was replaced by the existing structure in 1902. The appointment was part
of the 4-point East Freedom charge (Canoe Creek, East Freedom, Mount Moriah and
Pine Grove). The last reported membership was 16 in 1945, but the church
had been inactive for several years.
Final disposition:
The property is privately owned. The church
building is now a house, and the cemetery tombstones combine with vegetation to
form an interesting backyard.
45. Sandy Run UB
Location: Antis Road
Municipality: Antis township
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Exit northwest Altoona on Wopsononock
Avenue, the original trail through Logan Valley, which becomes Grandview Road
(aka Bellwood Road). Go 4 miles on Wopsononock/Grandview
to Antis Road (the next road past Lower Riggles Gap
Road). Turn right on Antis Road and go 0.5 miles to the cemetery on the
right. The 1873 atlas of Blair County indicates the exact location.
Historic Conference:
Allegheny Conference of the United Brethren
Church
Journal references:
Brief History:
The building here was erected about 1830 on land owned
by Alexander Ale. This was the first church building of any denomination
in Antis township. This church hosted the 2nd
annual (1840) session of the Allegheny Conference. The appointment continued to exist after the
Bellwood class erected a church building in 1892 ― but
eventually it was clear that Bellwood was the population center, and the
appointment was abandoned. The building was razed in 1894.
Final disposition:
The cemetery is maintained by the Calvary United
Methodist [former United Brethren] in Bellwood.
46. Sandy Run UB [different from previous church?]
[no picture]
Location:
Municipality:
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
Historic Conference:
Allegheny Conference of the United Brethren
Church
Journal references:
1912,98 –
permission to sell
Brief History:
Altoona Greenwood claims to be
“the successor to the frame Sandy Run Church erected by the United Brethren
about 1860 on the other side of old US 220.” And their history indicates
that in 1897 the congregation erected a brick church at the present location
that became known as the Greenwood Church.
Final disposition:
47. Sproul ME
Location: village of Sproul
Municipality: Greenfield township
County: Blair
State: PA
Directions:
The village of Sproul is off the old US 220, to the east, 2
miles south of Claysburg.
Historic Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of the
Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
Brief History:
A village grew up around the Sarah Furnace complex and was
furnished with a church, school and storehouse by ironmaster Peter Shoenberger. The Sarah Furnace village had just about
disappeared by the turn of the century. In 1911 the General
Refractories Company decided to build a plant at the site of Sarah Furnace
and by 1917 the company had constructed sixty-eight company-owned houses for
its workers. The town was named for then General Refractories
president, William C. Sproul.
The Methodist church at Sproul first
appears on the Claysburg charge, with a membership of 24, in the 1926
statistics. Its lasted reported membership is 56 in the 1960
journal, and it appears without membership figures as late as 1965. While
Sproul was a fairly enduring and successful appointment, it is unclear what, if
any, ownership the Methodists had in the building.
Final disposition:
Extra/Unknown
Central Pennsylvania Conference Methodist Episcopal
1885,49 –
addition erected at “Logan” church building
48.
Tyrone
Good Shepherd UMC
[Columbia Avenue]
Address:
1650 Clay Avenue
Municipality: borough of Tyrone
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
Clay Avenue is a north-south street in the
northwest part of Tyrone. From the old
US 220, go west on PA 453. PA 453 leaves
Pennsylvania Avenue (old US 220 in the north end of Tyrone on 14th
Street, and then makes a jog to the north and becomes 15th
Street. Clay Street crosses 15th
Street 5 blocks west of the jog in PA 453.
Turn north on Clay Street and go 3 blocks. The church is straight ahead.
Historic
Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of
the Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
Brief
History:
This congregation began as an outreach of First (now Wesley Church) into the community
then known as East Tyrone. A small
chapel was erected in 1871 on the hill along what is now 21st
Street. This church was known as the
East Tyrone or the Tyrone Second Methodist Episcopal Church.
In 1891 the congregation relocated
to Columbia Avenue and 18th Street and became known as the Columbia
Avenue ME Church. In 1917 the building
was considerably remodeled and enlarged.
Another major remodeling occurred in 1939.
In 1972 the congregation relocated
to its present location on Clay Avenue and adopted the name Church of the Good
Shepherd, commonly referred to as Good Shepherd UMC.
On 2/5/2023 the congregation
voted 68-11 to disaffiliate from the United Methodist Church, and that
disaffiliation along with 140 others was approved at a 5/17/2023 special
session of the Susquehanna Conference.
49. Williamsburg First UMC
Address:
431 W. Second Street
Municipality: borough of
Williamsburg
County: Blair County
State: PA
Directions:
From Hollidaysburg, go 9 miles east on US 22, one mile past Canoe Creek,
to PA 866. Turn south on PA 866 and go 4
miles to Williamsburg. PA 866 enters
Williamsburg on First Street. Second
Street is one block south. Turn South
onto Plum Street (on block before PA 866 turns to the right onto High Street)
and go one block. The church is on the
corner of Second and Plum Streets.
Historic
Conference:
Central Pennsylvania Conference of
the Methodist Episcopal Church
Journal references:
Brief
History:
The first Methodist circuit rider is
supposed to have preached in Williamsburg as early as 1792. The first land specifically deeded to the
Methodists, in 1812, was on the west side of High Street opposite the
spring. Tradition says a brick church
was erected that was also available to other denominations.
In 1831 the Methodists erected a
church on West Second Street, which served the congregation until the present
property was purchased in 1852. The
educational unit was added in 1951. At
this time the old sanctuary was razed and the congregation worshiped in the
educational unit until the present sanctuary was completed in 1952.
On 3/7/2023 the congregation
voted 68-12-1 to disaffiliate from the United Methodist Church, and that
disaffiliation along with 140 others was approved at a 5/17/2023 special
session of the Susquehanna Conference.
Final disposition: